SpiritRock Shop
Museum Specimens
Hello fellow Sci-Fi lovers!
I don't think any sci-fi movie made had a more recognizable observation station
than the famous Palomar Observatory. Palomar Observatory is home to a 200 inch
Hale Telescope which is shown in many of the 1950's and early 1960's sci-fi
movies that deals with aliens or monsters from outer space.

...As it turns out there are a myriad of telescopes all over the world watching the
skies and you can be a part of real history by participating in the SETI at Home
program. Movies like "Contact" with Jodie Foster as Dr. Eleanor Arroway portrayed
as the "High Priestess of the Desert" while at the VLA in Socorro N.M. may have
been scripted, but the Telescope Array exists in real life, the same as the Arecibo
telescope where Dr. Arroway began her extraterrestrial studies in Puerto Rico.
Palomar Observatory
San Diego, California
Search for Extraterrestrial
Visiting another civilization on a distant world would be fascinating, but at present such a trip is beyond our capabilities. However, it is
perfectly within our capabilities to develop a communications system using a powerful transmitter and a sensitive receiver, and using it to
search the sky for alien worlds whose citizens have a similar inclination. SETI is still no trivial task. Our Galaxy is 100,000 light-years across,
and contains a hundred thousand million stars. Searching the entire sky for some faraway and faint signal is an exhausting exercise.

About 10% of the stars in our Galaxy are Sun-like, and there are about a thousand such stars within 100 light-years of our Sun. These stars
would be useful primary targets for interstellar listening. However, we only know of one planet where life exists, our own. There is no way to
know if any of the simplifying assumptions are correct, and so as a second priority the entire sky must be searched.
Searching the entire sky is difficult enough. To find a radio transmission from an alien civilization, we also have to search through most of the
useful radio spectrum, since there is no way to know what frequencies aliens might be using. Trying to transmit a powerful signal over a wide
range of wavelengths is impractical, and so it is likely that such a signal would be transmitted on a relatively narrow band. This means that a
wide range of frequencies must be searched at every spatial coordinate of the sky.

There is also the problem of knowing what to listen for, since we have no idea how a signal sent by aliens might be modulated, and how the
data transmitted by it encoded. Narrow-bandwidth signals that are stronger than background noise and constant in intensity are obviously
interesting, and if they have a regular and complex pulse pattern are likely to be artificial. However, while studies have been performed on
how to send a signal that could be easily decoded, there is no way to know if the assumptions of those studies are valid, and deciphering the
information from an alien signal could be very difficult.

There is yet another problem in listening for interstellar radio signals. Cosmic and receiver noise sources impose a threshold to power of
signals that we can detect. For us to detect an alien civilization 100 light-years away that is broadcasting "omnidirectionally" -- in all directions
-- the aliens would have to be using a transmitter power equivalent to several thousand times the entire current power-generating capacity of
the entire Earth. It is much more effective in terms of communication to generate a narrow-beam signal whose "effective radiated power" is
very high along the path of the beam, but negligible everywhere else. This makes the transmitter power perfectly reasonable, but the problem
then becomes one of having the good luck to be in the path of the beam.

Such a beam might be very hard to detect, not only because it is very narrow but because it could be blocked by interstellar dust clouds or
garbled by "multipath effects" -- the same phenomenon that causes "ghosted" analog TV images. Such ghosts occur when TV transmissions
are bounced off a mountain or other large object, while also arriving at our TV antenna by a shorter, direct route, with the TV picking up two
signals separated by a delay. Similarly, interstellar narrowbeam communications could be bent or "refracted" by cosmic gas clouds to
produce multipath effects that could obscure the signal. If interstellar signals are being transmitted on narrow beams, there is nothing we can
do at this end to deal with this problem other than to be alert.

In 1960, Cornell University astronomer Frank Drake performed the first modern SETI experiment, named Project "Ozma", after the Queen of
Oz in Frank L. Baum's fantasy books. Drake used a 25-meter-diameter radio telescope at Green Bank, West Virginia, to examine the stars
Tau Ceti and Epsilon Eridani near the 1.420 gigahertz marker frequency. A 400 kilohertz band was scanned around the marker frequency,
using a single-channel receiver with a bandwidth of 100 hertz. The information was stored on tape for off-line analysis. Nothing of great
interest was found.

The first SETI conference took place at Green Bank in 1961. The Soviets took a strong interest in SETI during the 1960s, and beginning in
1964 performed a number of searches with omnidirectional antennas in hopes of picking up powerful radio signals. In 1966, American
astronomer and pop-science figure Dr. Carl Sagan and Soviet astronomer Iosif S. Shkolovskii published in collaboration a landmark book in

In 1971, the US National Aeronautics & Space Administration (NASA) funded a SETI study that involved Drake, Bernard Oliver of
Hewlett-Packard Corporation, and others. The report that resulted proposed the construction of an Earth-based radio telescope array with
1,500 dishes, known as Project "Cyclops". The price tag for the Cyclops array was $10 billion USD, and unsurprisingly Cyclops was not built.
However, in 1973 a SETI observation program was begun at Ohio State University using the "Big Ear" radio telescope, an ingenious
home-grown instrument that consisted of two fencelike arrays arranged on the ends of a metal-covered flat court. The transmitter part of the
array was parabolic, staring across the court to a flat rectangular reflector array that could hinge up and down.

The Big Ear could be aimed in altitude but not in azimuth, but it was intended as a survey instrument and that wasn't a major limitation. It was
originally used to map wideband radio sources through the sky, but due to funding cutbacks that mission had to be abandoned; the SETI
search, inspired by the debate about the Cyclops array, could be performed much more cheaply. During its SETI search, the Big Ear picked
up a startling narrowband signal on 15 August 1977, known as the "WOW!" signal for the note one of the staff scribbled on the computer
printout. The signal was not repeated and there are strong suspicions it was from some local source, possibly a military satellite. Searches
continued into 1985; the Big Ear was dismantled in 1998.

In 1974, an attempt was made to send a message to other worlds. A 1,679 bit message was transmitted from the 305-meter Arecibo radio
observatory dug into the ground in Puerto Rico toward the globular star cluster M13, about 25,000 light-years away. The pattern of 1s and
0s defined a 23 by 73 pixel "bitmap" image that included numbers, stick figures, chemical formulas, and a crude image of the Arecibo radio
telescope itself. The 23 by 73 grid was chosen because as prime numbers, they are the only integer values that can be multiplied together
to get 1,679, and hopefully alien listeners would be able to factor the number of pixels and recognize that they represented a grid. Given the
distance to M13 and the cryptic appearance of the bitmap, the experiment amounted mostly to a publicity stunt.

In 1979, Sagan, Bruce Murray, and Louis Friedman founded the US Planetary Society, partly as a vehicle for SETI studies. That same year,
the University of California at Berkeley launched a SETI project named "Search for Extraterrestial Radio from Nearby Developed Populations
(SERENDIP)", run by astronomer Daniel Werthimer. SERENDIP's search, as its named implied, was opportunistic, using auxiliary receivers
on radio telescopes which were performing observations having nothing to do with SETI. As long as they were searching the sky, however,
Werthimer figured they might as well check to see if there was an ET civilization there as well.

In the early 1980s, Harvard University physicist Paul Horowitz took the next step and proposed the design of a spectrum analyzer specifically
intended to search for SETI transmissions. Traditional desktop spectrum analyzers were of little usefulness for this job, since they sampled
frequencies using banks of analog filters and so were restricted in the number of channels they could acquire. However, modern
integrated-circuit digital signal processing (DSP) technology could be used to build "autocorrelation" receivers to check far more channels.

This work led in 1981 to a portable spectrum analyzer named "Suitcase SETI" that had a capacity of 131,000 narrowband channels. After
field tests that lasted into 1982, Suitcase SETI was put into use in 1983 with the 25-meter Harvard/Smithsonian radio telescope at Harvard,
Massachusetts. This project was named "Sentinel", and continued into 1985.

Even 131,000 channels weren't enough to search the sky in detail at any fast rate, and so Suitcase SETI was followed in 1985 by Project
"META (Megachannel Extra-Terrestial Array)". The META spectrum analyzer had a capacity of 8 million channels and a channel resolution
of 0.5 hertz. The project was led by Horowitz with the help of the Planetary Society, and was partly funded by moviemaker Steven Spielberg.
A second such effort, META II, was begun in Argentina in 1990 to search the southern sky. META II is still in operation, after an equipment
upgrade in 1996.

The next year, in 1986, UC Berkeley initiated their second opportunistic SETI effort, SERENDIP II, and has continued with two more
SERENDIP efforts to the present day. The current effort, SERENDIP IV, began in 1997, using the Arecibo dish. A "Southern SERENDIP"
effort was begun in 1998 in Australia using the 64-meter radio telescope at Parkes, plus systems derived from the other SERENDIP efforts.

In 1992, the US government finally funded an operational SETI program, in the form of the NASA "Microwave Observing Program (MOP)".
MOP was planned as a long-term effort, performing a "Targeted Search" of 800 specific nearby stars, along with a general "Sky Survey" to
scan the sky. MOP was to be performed by radio dishes associated with the NASA Deep Space Network, as well as a 43-meter dish at
Green Bank and the big Arecibo dish. The signals were to be analyzed by spectrum analyzers, each with a capacity of 15 million channels.
These spectrum analyzers could be ganged to obtain greater capacity. Those used in the Targeted Search had a bandwidth of 1 hertz per
channel, while those used in the Sky Survey had a bandwidth of 30 hertz per channel.

MOP drew the attention of the US Congress, where the program was strongly ridiculed, and was cancelled a year after its start. SETI
advocates did not give up, and in 1995 the nonprofit "SETI Institute" of Mountain View, California, resurrected the work under the name of
Project "Phoenix", backed by private sources of funding. Project Phoenix, under the direction of Dr. Jill Tarter, who had worked on MOP
when she was at NASA, was a continuation of the Targeted Search program, studying 710 Sunlike stars within 150 light-years of the Earth.
Phoenix used the 64-meter Parkes radio telescope in Australia, the 43-meter telescope at Green Banks, and the Arecibo dish, searching 70
million channels across a bandwidth of 1,800 MHz. The search was said to be capable of picking up any transmitter about as powerful as an
airport radar within 200 light-years. Phoenix was completed in March 2004, with negative results.

The Planetary Society followed up the META project with a more ambitious effort, named "BETA (Billion-Channel Extraterrestial Array)". This
was a dedicated DSP box with 200 processors and 3 gigabytes of RAM. BETA was about a trillion times more powerful than the signal
processing equipment used in Project Ozma. BETA actually only scanned 250 million channels, with a range of 0.5 hertz per channel,
searching through the microwave range from 1.400 to 1.720 gigahertz in eight hops, with two seconds of observation in each hop. BETA
was turned on in 1995, originally using a radio telescope at Oak Ridge, Tennessee; the project abruptly ended in 1999 when the radio
telescope being used for the search was wrecked in a windstorm.

The SETI Institute is now collaborating with the Radio Astronomy Laboratory at UC Berkeley to develop a specialized radio telescope array
for SETI studies, something like a mini-Cyclops array. The new array concept was originally named the "One Hectare Telescope (1HT)",
because it is to cover 100 meters on a side, but it is now known as the "Allen Telescope Array (ATA)", named after donor Paul Allen, a
co-founder of Microsoft. The first ten dishes were set up in 2002, leading to initial operational capability with 42 dishes in late 2007.
Ultimately, the array will consist of 350 dishes.

Final cost is expected be a modest $26 million USD. The SETI Institute is providing money for building the ATA, while UC Berkeley is building
the telescope and will provide operational funding. Berkeley astronomers will use the ATA to pursue other deep space radio observations.
The ATA is intended to support a large number of simultaneous observations through a technique known as "multibeaming", in which DSP
technology is used to sort out signals from the multiple dishes. The DSP system planned for the ATA is extremely ambitious. It is being seen
as a prototype of sorts for an even more ambitious system, the "Square Kilometer Array (SKA)", which of course will be a kilometer on a side
and will be a powerful tool for radio astronomy and SETI studies.

Private citizens are also involved in SETI. A private SETI organization, the "SETI League", was established in 1994, and in 1996 the group
began their own coordinated search program, "Project Argus". It can be thought of as something like an amateur radio organization with a
focus on interstellar communications. The stations are based on old-style TV dish receiver antennas running about 3 to 5 meters in
diameter; receiver sensitivity is about the same as that of the Big Ear telescope. The ultimate goal is to have 5,000 stations all over the
world; at last count, there were over 100.

The SETI Institute got private citizens involved with SETI through a program called "SETI@home" began in May 1999 and ran through 2001.
SETI@home allowed hobbyists to get involved with SETI research by simply downloading screen saver software over the Internet. The
software performed signal analysis on a downloaded 350 kilobyte "work unit" of SERENDIP IV SETI radio survey data, and then reports the
results back over the Internet. Millions of computer users in hundreds of countries signed up for SETI@home and provided hundreds of
thousands of hours of computer processing time. The project was widely praised in the computer press as an interesting exercise in
home-grown "distributed computing". A follow-on project was initiated after the first effort, and now SETI@home is an ongoing thing.
The development of the telescope in the 17th century was one of the first great
revolutions in astronomy, opening up the details of the sky in the visible-light range.
However, by the beginning of the 20th century astronomers knew that there were
other parts of the electromagnetic spectrum that were invisible, and which could reveal
new aspects of the sky. Development of electronic systems during World War II
opened the door to the first region of the invisible sky to be observed, in the radio
wavelength band, leading to the introduction of the first radio telescopes in the
postwar period. This is a breif history of radio telescope technology.
In 1932, an engineer at Bell Laboratories in the US named Karl Jansky (1905:1950)
was searching for sources of radio interference in the sky. He created an array of
antennas mounted on a circular track to see if sources could be found in specific
directions, and detected radio emissions coming from what he concluded in 1935 to
be the center of our Galaxy. He had made one of the first useful observations of the
cosmos outside the narrow visible-light window.

To the extent that anyone had considered natural radio sources in the sky, the
assumption was that the Sun would be the predominant source, and Jansky's finding
was surprising. Actually, it might be better said that it would have been surprising -- if
anyone had paid much attention to it. Bell Labs publicized Jansky's findings, but few
astronomers noticed. Jansky wanted to go farther, constructing a 30 meter (100 foot)
dish antenna to get a real map of the radio sky, but Bell Labs wasn't in the astronomy
business and, reasonably, didn't see that the expenditure was justified. Jansky went
on to other fields of research.

Jansky's findings were published in the popular radio press and did attract the
attention of an American amateur radio enthusiast named Grote Reber (1911:2002).
Reber was a very clever and energetic tinkerer, and put up a dish antenna with a
diameter of 9 meters in the backyard of his mother's house in Wheaton, Illinois. It was
an "elevation only" instrument, capable of being shifted up and down, but not rotated
around. Reber used the first real radio telescope to make the first real radio map of
the sky, and mailed his results to Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar (1910:1995) of the
University of Chicago, a prominent astrophysicist who was then editor of the
Chandrasekhar wasn't too sure of what to make of Reber and so he suggested that a
few astronomers drive to Wheaton and look things over. They weren't too sure of what
to make of things either, but after they arrived they realized that Reber knew exactly
what he was doing. Chandrasekhar approved Reber's article for publication.
Jesse Greenstein (1909:2002) of the University of Chicago had been one of the few
astronomers to pay any attention to Karl Jansky's work, and Greenstein really wanted
to encourage Reber, who he described as the "ideal American inventor." Greenstein
tried to arrange a position for Reber at the University of Chicago, but Reber was "an
independent cuss", as Greenstein put it, and didn't want to put up with any of the
bureaucracy involved.

The American way of invention sometimes seems to be to come up with a brilliant new
idea, then essentially not bother to follow up on it. Other nations take the next big
steps and then the Americans get in a hurry to catch back up. This more or less
happened with submarines and airplanes; it certainly happened with radio astronomy.
Although a British researcher, J.S. Hey, had monitored radio waves from the Sun in
1942 while trying to track down sources of interference for the military, nobody had
time or resources to pursue radio astronomy during World War II. However, after the
war a number of researchers who had been working on radar and other military
electronics during the conflict went back to academia with heads full of bright ideas.
They also had access to a large amount of new radio gear that had been developed
during the war, to be sold off as surplus as it rapidly became obsolescent or was
thrown out in defense cuts.

A number of radio astronomy research teams were formed, mostly in Britain and
Australia, with three teams leading the way: a group under Bernard Lovell (born 1913)
at the University of Manchester in the UK and operating at the Jodrell Bank site; a
group under Martin Ryle (1918:1984) at the University of Cambridge in the UK; and a
team under J.L. Pawsey (1908:1962) and John Bolton in Australia. They worked
mostly with arrays of simple antennas, wired together through electronic delay lines to
give the position of cosmic radio emitters through interferometry. These arrays were
cheap and could give locations, though they couldn't provide a real image of the radio
By 1949 the Australians had achieved a resolution of 10 arc-minutes, and had pinned
down three cosmic radio source, the most prominent of them being the Crab Nebula.
By 1951 Ryle's team had achieved a resolution of 1 arc-minute, leading to the
discovery of a radio-emitting galaxy, designated "Cygnus A".
Astronomers had also learned to use the radio emissions of various atoms and
molecules as "tracers" of cosmic structures. One of the first, and still the most
important, was the 21 centimeter radio emission of monatomic hydrogen. This
relatively longwave radiation could penetrate through cosmic dust clouds, and since
neutral hydrogen was an important constituent of the gas clouds that mark the spiral
arms of our Galaxy, the signal could be used to trace the spiral arms. The first map of
the structure of our Galaxy was published in 1951 by an American-Australian-Dutch
group; it was a feat that would have astounded astronomers of previous eras.

As the British and Australians blazed paths in radio astronomy, the Americans
continued to sit on their hands. Jesse Greenstein found the situation frustrating and
decided to take action. At the time, in the early 1950s, Greenstein was at Caltech,
working on the organization of an observing program for the new Hale telescope.
Greenstein wanted Caltech to fund a radio interferometer array, but the authorities
were cautious about the matter. To push the issue, Greenstein set up an international
conference on radio astronomy in Washington DC in early 1954.
The conference brought emerging American interest in radio astronomy to a boil. With
backing from the US National Science Foundation (NSF), a group of researchers set
up a government-backed "National Radio Astronomy Observatory (NRAO)" in
Greenbank, West Virginia. Of course, Greenstein got his radio interferometer array as
well, which was built by Caltech in Owens Valley, California.
* While the Americans were getting up to speed, radio astronomers elsewhere were
not idle. In 1957, the Jodrell Bank site put Bernard Lovell's "Mark I" radio telescope
into operation. It was the biggest fully steerable radio telescope, 76.2 meters in
diameter. It was used to track early space shots and occasionally showed up as a
background prop in sci-fi shows like DR WHO. It was upgraded in 1970:1971 and
2001:2003; it was renamed the "Lovell Telescope" after the second upgrade. A
number of other, smaller radio telescopes have been set up at or near the Jodrell
Bank site, which is open to the public as an arboretum.

The Australians, who had been having a running competition with the British, set up
the largest steerable radio telescope in the Southern Hemisphere at Parkes in New
South Wales in 1961. It has a diameter of 64 meters.

One of the other things about the odd American tendency to start something and then
drop is that, once they pick it up again, they overcompensate and try to build
something bigger and better than anything else. In the case of radio astronomy, the
US funded construction of the world's biggest radio telescope, at Arecibo, Puerto Rico,
with a diameter of 305 meters.
The Arecibo instrument was dug into a depression between a set of hills. The antenna
bowl originally consisted of a wire mesh grid, set up with a spherical curvature, with
three towers around the edges that used cables to support a central receiving
platform. Spherical curvature was used because the telescope was, obviously, a
transit instrument; it could be steered to an extent, however, by adjusting the position
of the receiving platform, allowing the telescope to scan the sky 20 degrees around
the central axis of the dish. The spherical curvature permitted a reasonable focus no
matter what the position of the receiving platform was. The receiver system was
designed to compensate for the spherical aberration; as with most radio telescopes, it
included several different receivers to permit it to "tune in" on different wavelength

The Arecibo facility went online in November 1963. Interestingly, it was officially
designated as a facility for ionospheric studies, apparently as a way to get US
government funding. The Arecibo telescope has been updated since its
establishment. In the early 1970s, the dish was resurfaced with aluminum panels to
permit reception of shorter wavelengths. The panels were perforated to let sun and
light through; vegetation is allowed to grow under the dish to prevent soil erosion. It
was upgraded again in the 1990s, tripling its sensitivity.

The Arecibo dish was a grand project, but other groups in the US managed to perform
radio astronomy experiments on a budget. One of the most interesting was the Ohio
State University (OSU) "Big Ear" radio telescope, which went online in 1963. The Big
Ear was the brainchild of Dr. John D. Krause, who was a professor of both astronomy
and electrical engineering, making him ideally suited to developing such a project.

The Big Ear consisted of a two billboard arrays, with a mesh surface, arranged on the
ends of a metal-covered flat court that acted as a ground plane. The transmitter part
of the array was a fixed parabolic array, 110 meters wide and 21 meters tall and with
twin moveable feed horns. It stared flat across the court to a tiltable flat reflector array
104 meters wide and 30 meters tall when fully erect. The court was made of concrete
covered by aluminum panels, with a width of 110 meters and a spacing between the
two arrays of 152 meters.

The Big Ear could be aimed in altitude but not in azimuth, but it was intended as a
survey instrument and that wasn't a major limitation. It was originally used to map
wideband radio sources through the sky, but due to funding cutbacks that mission had
to be abandoned. In 1973, it was converted to conduct a pioneering search for extra-
terrestial signals, with the effort continuing into 1985. The Big Ear was finally
dismantled in 1998.
* Although the Arecibo instrument was and remains impressive, at the time the British
still retained the largest steerable dish, the Jodrell Bank instrument. The Germans
topped it in 1971 by setting up a 100 meter (328 foot) fully steerable dish at
Effelsburg, near Bonn. The biggest competing American instrument was a partly
steerable (elevation only) NRAO instrument with a diameter of 92 meters at Green
Bank, West Virginia. It collapsed in a storm in 1988, and was replaced about a decade
later by a fully steerable telescope with a diameter of 100 meters at the same site.
The new instrument is known as the "Green Bank Telescope (GBT)". It has an "offset"
feed / receiver assembly that minimizes obstruction of the sky. It also features a
surface consisting of 2,204 moveable panels that are adjusted by computer to ensure
an accurate surface, allowing it to operate effectively at wavelengths shorter than a

In any case, the establishment of more powerful and capable radio telescopes in the
1960s led to a series of major discoveries. One was the discovery of "quasi-stellar
radio sources" or "quasars" in 1963, radio-bright objects that appeared to be stars but
which were later determined to be distant galaxies with highly energetic core regions.
The third catalog of radio objects put together by the Cambridge group had noticed a
very bright radio source, with the catalog entry of "3C 273", but couldn't pin down its
exact location. The Parkes group realized that the Moon would pass through the
region of the sky where 3C 273; the Moon would block out the source at a precise
instant, allowing its location to be pinned down accurately enough to allow a big optical
telescope to take a picture of it. 3C 273 was so low on the horizon that the Parkes
staff had to saw off the stops on their telescope, but the trouble was worth it. The
location of 3C 273 was pinned down, the object was photographed, and its spectrum
indicated that it heavily redshifted, implying that it was an extremely bright source in
the very distant Universe.

Another was the 1967 discovery of radio pulsing stars or "pulsars", which were quickly
determined to be superdense "neutron stars", objects a few kilometers across with the
mass of a full-size star, composed mostly of densely-packed neutrons. Pulsars were
discovered by a British team under Anthony Hewish (born 1924), with his grad student
Jocelyn Bell (born 1943) being the first to notice the radio pulsations. They were using
a special dedicated array of 2,048 antennas, arranged in a grid over 1.8 hectares (4.5
acres) and designed to perform wide sky surveys for rapid radio transients in the
meter wavelengths. It was a thoroughly cheap home-brew system, little more than a
field full of light wooden poles strung with wires, but it proved very effective, and won
Hewish the Nobel prize in 1974, sharing the prize with Martin Ryle.
In 1974, two American astronomers, Russell A. Hulse (born 1950) and Joseph H.
Taylor (born 1941), spotted the first binary neutron star system using the Arecibo
instrument. They would also get the Nobel prize for their work, in 1993. Theoreticians
had determined that neutron stars were possible decades earlier, but they seemed so
preposterous that not everybody was convinced they were for real. The discovery of
pulsars indicated they were. Given that encouragement, astronomers became more
willing to believe in the existence of "black holes", objects denser than neutron stars,
so dense that light cannot escape from them.

With the introduction of large, powerful dish radio telescopes, astronomers began to
think of perform radar observations of the planets. Radar involves transmitting radio
pulses and then measuring the time it takes for the pulses to return from a target.
Obviously, this requires a powerful transmitter and a sensitive receiver since even the
nearest planets are far away.
Radar pulses had been reflected from the Moon not long after the end of World War II,
but this was basically a stunt. In fact, when the big US "Ballistic Missile Early Warning
System (BMEWS)" military radars were set up in Greenland and Alaska in the early
1960s, the first time the Moon rose in the line of sight of one of the radars it set off
alarms; the designers hadn't factored the Moon into their considerations, and some
changes had to be made to ignore the returns from the Moon.
In 1961 astronomers actually performed the first useful radar observations of another
world, bouncing radar pulses off of Venus during a conjunction of Earth and Venus.
The pulses were in the form of "pseudorandom noise" trains that provided long and
distinctive patterns, allowing the astronomers to sort out the returns. The radar
studies showed Venus had a slow rotation rate, and that it rotated in the reverse
direction of other planets, as if it had suffered some monster impact in the distant past
that reversed its spin.
In the 1970s, improved radar observations using the Arecibo instrument actually
permitted some mapping of gross surface detail on the planet as well, with the radar
penetrating the unending thick cloud cover of the planet. This was just a prelude for
much more detailed and comprehensive radar maps of the planet, produced by US
and Soviet Venus orbiting spacecraft in the 1980s.
By that time, radar was being used to observe asteroids passing by the Earth, leading
to the imaging of the asteroid Castalia in 1989. A number of other asteroids have
been imaged by radar since that time, and in fact radar observations of large
asteroids have been performed into the asteroid belt itself, beyond the orbit of Mars.

Radio interferometry has been around from almost the beginning of radio astronomy.
In radio interferometry, two separated radio antennas pick up radio waves from a
single cosmic source, with phase interference occurring if the paths from the source to
the antennas are not both an integer multiple of the wavelength being observed.
Measurement of the phase difference gives highly precise position information on a
point source. The resolution of radio interferometry is dependent on the baseline
between the two antennas, though the ability to collect radio waves is only
proportional to the sum of the areas of the two antennas, no matter how far they are
Radio interferometry is not too different in principle from optical interferometry, but the
long wavelengths observed by radio astronomers make radio interferometry less
demanding than optical interferometry, and the radio measurements are somewhat
easier to process as well. This is why radio interferometry is well-established but
optical interferomentry is only now becoming so.
The early radio interferometry arrays, as mentioned, were only capable of finding the
locations of radio emitters, being just simple antennas wired together through delay
lines, with the signals from the antennas electrically summed to find nulls and
maximums. In the 1950s, the Australians came up with a straightforward extension of
this idea, using two such arrays at right angles to each other to pin down sources in
two dimensions. A series of such "cross interferometers" were built at Fleurs, not far
from Sydney, beginning with the 1954 "Mills cross", followed by the larger "Shain
cross" in 1958.

Much more dramatically, in the 1960s, Martin Ryle came up with a scheme known as
"aperture synthesis" that instead of merely locating cosmic radio sources provided an
image of them as well. He won the Nobel prize for his invention.
The patterns of phase interference observed in radio interferometry define concentric
circles that shrink to a point at the precise location of the point source. The positions
of the two telescopes changes as the Earth moves, defining a path through the map of
concentric circles. The hints provided by the patterns along this path can be used to
reveal the exact position of the source.
This is the case for a point source, but for an extended source the object can be
regarded as a matrix of point sources, with the number of points in the image related
to the resolution of the interferometry array. A process known as "Fourier analysis"
allows the individual sources to be sorted out. As one astronomer put it, the data
obtained from an interferometer array is analogous to a series of pictures obtained
through a slowly rotating colander. The pictures can be mathematically combined to
rebuild the actual image. This process is known as "filling the aperture". As more
telescopes are added to an interferometer array, the observational data yields more
information. Aperture synthesis wasn't really practical until the computers became
relatively common, since it requires a good amount of number-crunching.

Early experiments in imaging radio interferometry were conducted in the late 1940s
using war surplus radio dishes. By the 1960s, small imaging radio interferometry
arrays had been developed, such as the British Cambridge "One Mile" (1.6 kilometer)
array, which provided resolutions on the order of a few arc-seconds. The Cambridge
array was later increased to a size of 5 kilometers (3.1 miles).
There are other significant imaging radio interferometers at Narrabi in Australia; the
Westerbork Radio Observatory in the Netherlands; and the United Kingdom. One of
the UK telescopes, known as "Merlin", consists of seven antennas spread over 200
kilometers in western and central England.

One of the most important dedicated imaging radio interferometry arrays is the 27-
element "Very Large Array (VLA)" at Socorro in New Mexico, completed in the 1970s,
which is built up of 27 25-meter dishes that can be moved on rails to provide a
maximum baseline of 40 kilometers (25 miles). It was built by the NRAO, using NSF
funding. It performed its first observations in 1975 and was fully operational in 1980.
Like the Jodrell Bank instrument, the VLA occasionally makes appearances in science-
fiction videos.

One of the traditional problems with radio astronomy was that for wavelengths longer
than about 30 centimeters (1 gigahertz), ionospheric interference makes it difficult to
obtain a decent map of a radio source. In 1991, astronomers figured out algorithms to
correct for ionospheric interference, and managed to obtain radio maps from the VLA
at a record long wavelength of about four meters (74 megahertz).

One of the latest imaging radio interferometers is at Narayangaon, near Pune in India.
The "Giant Meterwave Radio Telescope (GMRT)" came online in 2000; it was
designed to focus on long wavelengths generally neglected by other radio telescopes.
It has thirty 45 meter dishes with a maximum baseline of 25 kilometers, performs
observations in six bands from 38 MHz to 1.420 GHz (7.9 meters and 21 centimeters).
The GMRT was built by India's Tata Institute of Fundamental Research. The long
wavelengths mean the dishes didn't need to have the surface precision of radio
telescopes that operate at shorter wavelengths; they are wire-mesh reflectors
mounted on steel-tube frames kept in shape with steel cables, greatly reducing cost
and incidentally giving them an attractive, delicate appearance. Its many tasks include
searches and observations of "protoclusters" of galaxies in the early Universe, and
also studies of pulsars. Its near-equatorial position gives it a good view of the plane of
the Milky Way, allowing it to hunt down large numbers of pulsars.

Arrays now seem to be replacing large unitary radio telescopes. Scaling up structures,
such as a radio telescope, tends to run into diminishing returns: in very simple terms,
doubling the linear dimensions means increasing the structure's cross section by a
factor of four while mass and volume increase by a factor of eight. That means
doubling the stress on the structure, which has to be made all that much more

Martin Ryle no doubt never predicted at the outset that the computing power that
made aperture synthesis possible would evolve so fast; by the 21st century, an
average household would have a more powerful computer than almost any available
in the 1960s. Given modern computing power, it is much simpler and cheaper to build
an array of small antennas and link them together with aperture synthesis; some
astronomers believe the big unitary telescope is now a thing of the past.
One of the pioneering examples of this new approach, the "Allen Telescope Array
(ATA)", is gradually being put in place in the Lassen National Forest in northern
California, a somewhat isolated area where radio noise is relatively subdued. The ATA
will ultimately consist of an array of 350 six meter (20 foot) dishes; at last notice, it was
up to 32 dishes, but new dishes are being installed on an ongoing basis. It was
originally called the "One Hectare Telescope (1HT)" since a hectare (2.47 acres) was
the objective for total collecting area.

In completion, it will have the same effective collecting area as the 100 meter NRAO
Green Bank telescope, but will cost only about a third as much. All the sources of
funding are private -- it named after its primary patron, Paul Allen (born 1953), a
senior official at Microsoft -- and the bureaucratic overhead is minimal. It is operated
by a private group in collaboration with the University of California at Berkeley and is
primarily focused on the search for other civilizations in space, but of course it can be
used for less speculative purposes as well.

Other new radio telescope arrays are being set up elsewhere. A group of Chinese,
Canadian, and American scientists has set up a pilot version of the "Primeval
Structure Telescope (PaST)" in the barren regions of western China. The pilot array
consists of 25 "pods", with 127 antennas per pod; the antennas are simple "Yagi"
types, nothing more than a set of dipoles of increasing span mounted on a bar, very
similar to the ordinary broadcast TV antenna. Dish antennas don't work very well for
wavelengths much longer than about two meters (150 meters); dipole arrays are not
only cheap, but they are actually superior to dishes for low-frequency work. At such
long wavelengths, they don't even need precision manufacture. The ultimate PaST
array will have 10,000 antennas covering three hectares (7.4 acres); the group hoped
to complete the instrument by the end of 2006.

An international group of radio astronomers became interested in building such "low
frequency arrays (LOFARs)" after the low-frequency VLA breakthrough in the early
1990s. PaST is only one result of this effort; others include:
•        A Dutch-German collaboration is now setting up a 25,000 antenna LOFAR array
distributed over an area about 350 kilometers (220 miles) in diameter, straddling the
border between the two countries.
•        A US group is working on a "Long Wavelength Array (LWA)" consisting of
10,000 antennas strung over 400 kilometers (250 miles) of the US SouthWest.
•        US and Australian researchers are now planning the "Mileura" array of 3,000
antennas in Western Australia.
Not only are these LOFARs cheap and powerful, they also have a wide field of view,
consisting effectively of the entire sky above them. Computing power can be used to
sort out the actual direction of any signal arriving at them. This makes them ideal for
picking up "transient" events, such as the radio component of short-lived high-energy
events in the distant Universe.
One of the most ambitious schemes for a next-generation instrument is the "Square
Kilometer Array (SKA)", an array of antennas that will actually have a total kilometer of
area, making it two orders of magnitude more sensitive than any previous radio
telescope. The SKA will operate at relatively short wavelengths and will be used to
probe the distant, early Universe; map the magnetic fields of galaxies; monitor
thousands of pulsars to track gravitational waves; and search for intelligent life in the

The SKA will be cheap for its capabilities, but it will still cost up to about $1.6 billion
USD. It is now being promoted as an international collaboration, with the main selling
point at present being mapping of galactic and extragalactic neutral hydrogen clouds
through the 21 centimeter emission. Of course, the SKA will have other capabilities. It
will be able to pick up the signals from carbon monoxide and other cosmic molecules
to map out the structures of distant galaxies; examine the violent cores of active
galaxies, where supermassive black holes may lurk, using the coherent microwave
emissions of clouds of stimulated water molecules called "mega-masers"; and trace
out the magnetic fields of nearby galaxies, giving hints of galactic structure.
The SKA is expected to have about 4,000 10-meter dish antennas operating over 1 to
25 GHz, supplemented by a set of fixed planar lowband radio receiver arrays
operating over 100 MHz to 1 GHz. Candidate sites have been narrowed down to
Mileura in Western Australia and Karoo in South Africa. The nation that hosts the site
will be required to control communications emissions to prevent unnecessary
interference with the operation of the SKA.

Both nations are building small demonstrator arrays at the proposed sites to evaluate
technologies. Detail design of the SKA is expected to begin in 2008. The first SKA
elements are expected to be in operation by 2014, with completion of the full array in

Along with the development of large radio interferometry arrays like the VLA,
techniques were developed to link radio telescopes spanning continents or oceans
into interferometry arrays, a technique known as "very long baseline interferometry
Even before the construction of the VLA, radio astronomers were considering VLBI.
The VLA is a "connected element" interferometer, with direct signal connections
between the dishes, but for longer baselines direct connections are not practical.
Observations had to be recorded on magnetic tape, along with the necessary precise
timing information, which required accuracies better than a microsecond. This meant
that any observatory participating in a VLBI network had to have recording equipment
linked to a precise local atomic clock.
The first experimental VLBI measurements were made in 1967 by several Canadian
and American research teams. A year later, a Swedish group joined the effort,
providing an intercontinental baseline for observations. By the early 1970s, VLBI
observations were providing details of the cosmic jets emitted by distant quasars.
The VLBI pioneers managed to perform some significant observations of radio
objects, but the logistics of conducting VLBI were burdensome and quickly exceeded
the capability of informal groups of researchers. In particular, trying to schedule
observations on multiple radio telescopes at the same time was troublesome, and
argued for a set of radio telescopes dedicated strictly to VLBI.
VLBI advocates joined together in the "Network Users Group", which lobbied for a
formal and properly funded VLBI effort in 1980 report on priorities for astronomical
research. The result was the American "Very Long Baseline Array (VLBA)", an array
of ten identical radio telescopes, each with a diameter of 25 meters, scattered across
the North American continent. The VLBA was funded by the NSF at a cost of $84
million US in 1989 dollars, and was formally dedicated in 1993. The VLBA provides the
highest resolution of any astronomical observatory ever built, up to a tenth of an arc-
The VLBA is controlled by the NRAO Array Operations Center (AOC) in Socorro, New
Mexico. The ten radio dishes, or network "nodes", are located at:
•        Kitt Peak, Arizona.
•        Pie Town, New Mexico.
•        Mauna Kea, Hawaii.
•        Owens Valley, California.
•        Brewster, Washington.
•        Los Alamos, New Mexico.
•        Fort Davis, Texas.
•        North Liberty, Iowa.
•        Hancock, New Hampshire.
•        Saint Croix, Virgin Islands.
The baselines between the ten nodes range from 200 to 8,000 kilometers (125 to
5,000 miles). Each node site has a small local staff to handle observations and routine
maintenance. The AOC provides central control over the entire network and a
dedicated VLBI processor, or "correlator", that crunches the observations from the ten
nodes. The AOC also maintains a spares stockpile, and an engineering staff to
provide high level repairs or upgrades for the nodes.
Early experiments with radio interferometry revealed a sky that was very different from
the one seen at visible wavelengths. The brightest objects were remote active galaxies
and quasars, and the visible counterparts of these bright objects could only be found
with powerful optical telescopes. The VLBA has greatly extended these early
While VLBI can provide the resolution equivalent to a radio telescope with a diameter
the size of the baselines between the individual telescopes, as mentioned the amount
of radio energy a VLBI network can pick up is still limited by the sum of the apertures
of the telescopes. This means that VLBI is best suited to relatively small cosmic
objects that are energetic emitters at radio wavelengths.
The best targets for VLBI have been the cores of active galaxies and quasars, where
violent and highly energetic events take place in a very small region. Astronomers
believe that the energy is being released by matter falling into central supermassive
black holes. This process releases 10 to 100 times more energy than the fusion
processes that takes place in stars, causing huge cosmic jets to flow from the core.
The interaction of these jets with the medium they pass through leads to strong radio
Optical and infrared telescopes generally observe radiation released by thermal
processes, such as light emitted by stars or heat released by the contraction of cool
cosmic dust clouds. Radio telescopes, in contrast, more generally observe radiation
caused by nonthermal processes, such as the continuous-spectrum "synchrotron
radiation" emitted by electrons curving through strong magnetic fields, or the line-
spectrum radiation emitted by gas clouds acting as "cosmic masers".
Clouds of water molecules can act as cosmic masers under some circumstances, and
maser emission from such clouds in the cores of distant galaxies has been used to
study their motion around central supermassive black holes. Using a few simple
physics calculations, the motions have revealed the mass of these black holes to
within a few percent.
Another useful target for radio astronomy observations is the 21 centimeter radio
wavelength emitted by cold hydrogen. The 21 centimeter radiation allows the creation
of maps of hydrogen clouds in our Galaxy and other galaxies. The VLBA has also
been used to observe pulsars and events in our galactic core.

The VLBA is a work in progress. In 1997, the Japanese launched the HALCA (High
Altitude Laboratory for Communications & Astronomy) satellite, which is a radio
telescope platform with a folding antenna 8 meters in diameter. Although an
experiments was performed with a communications satellite in the late 1980s to
demonstrate that satellites could be used as part of a VLBI network, HALCA was the
first spacecraft to be specifically designed for the purpose.
HALCA had a highly elliptical orbit around the Earth that allows it to perform VLBI
observations over a baseline as long as 30,000 kilometers. Although HALCA's
communication system suffered a failure that has limited the usefulness of its
observations, it performed practical validations of a space-based VLBI system.
The SKA, described previously, will actually be a VLBI system. Only about half the
array, as determined by collecting area, will be at a central location. The other
elements will be placed at sites up to thousands of kilometers away to provide VLBI

The large radiotelescopes and interferometers typically operate at the meter and
centimeter wavelengths. The signals are broadband, continuous, and often generated
by "synchrotron emission", the radiation emitted by electrons spiraling in a magnetic
Beginning in the 1980s, radio astronomers began to move into wavelengths of a few
millimeters or less. Such "millimeter" and "submillimeter" emissions, nudging up to the
infrared spectrum at the short end of the scale, are generally from the different
molecules that make up cold interstellar clouds of gas and dust, such as carbon
monoxide, water, or a surprisingly wide range of organic molecules. Carbon monoxide
is a particularly important target, because it is the second most common molecule in
such clouds, next to diatomic hydrogen (H2), and can be used as a "tracer" to reveal
the presence of H2. Such observations can be used to map the structures of galaxies
or probe in detail into the inner regions of clouds where stars are being formed.
There are two problems with observing the Universe at millimeter and submillimeter
wavelengths. First, the emissions are weak, requiring receivers cooled to a few
degrees Kelvin to reduce thermal and electronic noise. Second, these emissions are
absorbed by atmospheric water vapor. Telescopes designed to observe this region of
the spectrum have to be placed on top of high, dry mountains.
One of the best millimeter-wave telescope in the world is the French-German-Spanish
Institute de Radio Astronomie Millimetrique's 30 meter (100 foot) diameter dish high in
the mountains of Spain's Sierra Nevada, not far from Granada. This instrument has
been in operation since the mid-1980s, and makes extensive use of insulation, fans,
and other components to control temperature and minimize thermal deformations.
Other notable millimeter-wave instruments include the 45 meter (150 foot) Nobeyama
telescope in Japan, and a 12 meter (40 foot) dish operated by the US NRAO on Kitt
Peak, Arizona. The Kitt Peak telescope covers almost the entire millimeter spectrum,
and has discovered a large number of the molecules currently known to exist in deep
space. There are over a dozen smaller instruments scattered around the world, and
several projects are underway to build new instruments.
One of the best submillimeter telescopes is the 15 meter (50 meter) James Clerk
Maxwell telescope on Mauna Kea, a British-Dutch-Canadian venture. It is
accompanied on Mauna Kea by the California Institute of Technology 10.4 meter (34
foot) Submillimeter Observatory. A 10 meter (33 foot) submillimeter telescope is now in
operation on Mount Graham, near Tucson. It is run jointly by the Max Planck Institut
fur Radioastronomie in Bonn, Germany, and the Steward Observatory of the
University of Arizona.
A 50 meter millimeter-wave telescope is now in operation on the top of the mountain of
Sierra Negre in central Mexico, at an altitude of 4,640 meters, with a good view of both
northern and southern skies. The "Large Millimeter Telescope (LMT)" was a
collaborative project of Mexico's Instituto Nacional de Astrofisica, Optica y Electronica
(INAOE) and the University of Massachusetts at Amherst, with substantial funding from
the US Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA). DARPA provided
funding because the LMT promised to advance technologies useful for tracking near-
space objects and for millimeter-wave radars, though there were protests in Mexico
over the involvement of a US defense agency in the project.
Interferometry is being used in millimeter astronomy, with four now in operation. The
Owens Valley Radio Observatory in California has six antennas and is run by the
California Institute of Technology. A consortium of the Universities of California, Illinois,
and Maryland also operate a six-antenna interferometer at Hat Creek in California,
and expect to upgrade this instrument to nine antennas soon.
In addition, there are millimeter-wave interferometers at Nobeyama, and on the
Plateau de Bure in France, where the Institut de Radio Astronomie Millimetrique
operates an instrument comprising four 15-meter antennas, with a fifth to be added
A submillimeter array, with six 6-meter dishes, is being built on Mauna Kea by the
Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory, based at Harvard University. This array will
consist of six 6-meters dishes arranged in a pattern 500 meters across, and will have
a resolution down to 0.1 arc-seconds.

None of these arrays is on the scale of the VLA, but in November 2003 ground was
broken on the Atacama plateau in Chile for the "Atacama Large Millimeter Array
(ALMA)", which in completion will be the largest millimeter wave astronomical facility in
the world. It will consist of 50 (originally 64) precision dish antennas, each with a
diameter of 12 meters. The antennas are steerable and moveable, and will be used to
form interferometer arrays ranging from 150 meters to 14 kilometers across. The dry
climate and the site altitude of 5,000 meters provides excellent "seeing"; the control
station is on lower ground, where breathing is not as difficult.

ALMA is being built by a consortium of US, ESO, Japan, Canadian, and Spanish
research institutions. The group has set up and is operating a 12 meter submillimeter
telescope at Atacama named the "Atacama Pathfinder Experiment (APEX)". As its
name implies, it is intended to validate technologies and procedures for ALMA, but it is
also the largest submillimeter instrument in the southern hemisphere. The Japanese
are to build a secondary array, the "Atacama Compact Array (ACA)", with four 12-
meter dishes and twelve 7-meter dishes, which will be optimized to observe wide-area,
diffuse objects. The full ALMA array is expected to go into preliminary operation in
2007 and be completed in 2012.

Many Thanks to Greg Goebel’s “In the Public Domain” for his
research and public domain sharing of this information.
"National Radio Astronomy Observatory / Associated Universities, Inc. /
National Science Foundation"
"National Radio Astronomy Observatory / Associated Universities, Inc. /
National Science Foundation"
"National Radio Astronomy Observatory / Associated Universities, Inc. /
National Science Foundation"
"National Radio Astronomy Observatory / Associated Universities, Inc. /
National Science Foundation"
"National Radio Astronomy Observatory / Associated Universities, Inc. /
National Science Foundation"
"National Radio Astronomy Observatory / Associated Universities, Inc. /
National Science Foundation"
VLA in Socorro, New Mexico
How to Join
Powered by...
Be a Part
of History!

Don't Just
read it...
MAKE it!

This program SETI@Home is
sponsored by and administered by
the University of California,

Berkeley Open Infrastructure for
Network Computing...

to join go to

download BOINC and select SETI
as your program!
click on the link below for more information about SETI worldwide efforts